« Previous Post | Index | Next Post »
Oops!
This really should have gone in with that last Hurt-Comfort post, I suppose, but I forgot all about it. So now Sexy!Moody gets to have his very own turn in the spotlight.
--------------
Cindy (hoping that I would someday write an essay making her feel better about her issues with Hagrid) wrote:
But . . . but . . . there is one male character who just doesn't fit the pattern at all: Moody. Now, I just love Moody because I'm drawn to his power and Toughness. And he sure has been injured enough times. And he is so alone and desperately needs the love of a good woman and all.
Um. Yes, well, like I said. People are...diverse. ;)
As for Hagrid, I seem to remember once getting myself into a spot of trouble with the Hagrid fans by calling him a "bigot." Wasn't that enough for you?
Cindy:
But good grief, is there a single person out there who can make the case that Moody is sexy? I mean it is difficult to even type Sexy!Moody.
And Eloise agreed:
I sure can't do it.
Hmmm. Well, let's see now....
Sexy!Moody. Sexy!Moody. Sexy!Moody.
Nope. Not having a problem with it. Although I am giggling over here, I'll have you know.
As for why there are no takers for Dead Sexy Moody, though...well, Eloise suggested:
There's a difference, I suppose between 'having suffered' and being horribly mutilated. . . . Moody physically appears to be irredeemable as a sex-object.
Yeah. "Horribly mutilated" is generally considered a turn-off, I'm afraid. Even more so than greasy hair and sallow skin and yellow teeth. Snape's physical drawbacks aren't sufficient to put him out of the running. Moody's are. Monstrously unjust, but there you have it.
Also, he's kind of old.
Oh, yes, yes, I know. What a terrible thing to say! That horrible ageist Elkins! But the books don't, on the whole, seem terribly interested in providing older readers with age-aligned crush material, much as they don't provide much in the way of crush material for readers who are attracted to women rather than to men. The Dead Sexy Mrs. Lestrange is just about all that's on offer for the gynophilic, and she's Ever So Evil, so unless you get a kick out of that whole dominatrix schtick, you're really out of luck. You're left with McGonagall, who is kind of hot in her own way, but who also never actually gets to do anything. The books are really very unfair that way.
While I'm on this line of thought, it's interesting to note that Harry's first impression of Lupin on the train is that, in spite of his grey hairs, he is "young." I have to say that I've always found this completely unbelievable. Thirteen year old boys do not consider men in their mid-30s "young." In fact, it's been my experience that adolescents view people in their thirties as positively ancient.
I've always suspected that we're seeing a little bit of blatant authorial intent seeping through in that passage, myself. I think that JKR wanted the reader to view Lupin as "young" primarily because she wanted to designate him as a romantically appealing character right from the very start.
Cindy:
Moody suffers, both before GoF and during GoF. But for some reason, I worry that I might not even like Real Moody, let alone sympathize with him. It does seem that JKR is trying to show him hurt yet brave about it. JKR really lays it on hick: "Stunned . . . very weak. . . . he's freezing."
He's unconscious. He's also missing his prosthetics, which is fairly pathetic, and not in at all a romantically appealing way.
We assume that he has indeed been brave about the whole thing because we have deduced both from Crouch Jr's masquerade and from all of the things that we've been told about Moody that he is brave and heroic and Tough. But we don't actually see him suffering nobly anywhere. In that scene, for example, he is unconscious and therefore incapable of doing much of anything, other than serving as the utterly passive recipient of a medical evaluation. The overall effect, I think, is far more one of pathos than of romantic suffering: Moody comes across there as a weak and victimized old man, which isn't at all a romantic image.
Later, Moody is in the hospital and is "motionless."
And once again: he's utterly passive. Complete passivity doesn't inspire very much in the way of romantic engagement.
Moody fights bravely before being subdued by Crouch Jr. and Wormtail.
Yeah, he does, but we're only told that. We don't actually see it happening. This gets back to what I was saying in my previous post, about readers being far more strongly influenced by things that they see directly than by the things that they learn in a more indirect fashion. We never see Moody struggle valiantly against a situation in which he is nonetheless compelled to suffer. We're just told that it happened, which isn't at all the same thing.
And why is Moody's portrayal at the staff table "extremely twitchy, jumping every time someone spoke to him" so unsatisfactory? Was that JKR's attempt to make sure that we don't begin to identify to closely with Moody? Is he supposed to be something other than heroic, hmmmmm?
Well, much as I would love to take it as evidence of Evil!Moody, if pressed to play 'guess the authorial intent' here, my instinct is to say that Moody's depiction there probably had far more to do with how JKR wanted to influence the reader to think about Crouch Jr. than about Moody himself. We know (or think we do, anyway) that Moody is One Tough Dude. So the fact that he's shown there as having been reduced to such a traumatized state implies some pretty dire things about how Crouch Jr. (whom we already know to be a sadist) might have been treating him over the course of the year.
I think that the intended effect was probably less likely to be to make us either gain or lose sympathy for Moody as it was to rouse us to righteous indignation on his behalf, and thus to dispel any lingering little feelings of sympathy that Crouch's pathetic confession and horrifying end might have inspired.
On the question of why Moody wouldn't be written in such a way as to strike readers as attractive, Eloise wrote:
Weeelll..... I suppose we can't have the whole book stuffed full crush material. Perhaps he's simply another variation on the theme of the unattractive good guy. The one that no-one, not even weird Snape-fans, find sexy. ;-)
Moody is a variant of a stock character: the Crazed Old Coot Mentor. JKR even has him swigging from that hip flask all the time. (The Crazed Old Coot Mentor is often also a drunk.)
It's not a character type who is meant to be sexy. Crazed Old Coot Mentors are hardly ever sexy. That's really just not a part of their function.
—Elkins
Posted to HPfGU by Elkins on May 30, 2002 3:32 PM
« Previous Post | Index | Next Post »